Ricky Carmichael Faces Backlash Over Comments on Malcolm Stewart’s Victory
Motocross legend Ricky Carmichael has come under heavy criticism following his comments on Malcolm Stewart’s recent victory, where he acknowledged the win but dismissed Stewart as a serious contender for the championship.
After Stewart secured his first-ever 450SX win, fans and analysts were celebrating what many considered a breakthrough moment. However, during a post-race discussion, Carmichael’s remarks struck a nerve when he said:
“Yes, Malcolm actually won. It’s a good thing to see him get a victory, but I don’t put him in the championship debate. He got a win with his brother in the booth, which was cool, but it wasn’t dominant.”
Fans and Riders React
Carmichael’s words sparked immediate backlash, with many questioning why a historic moment for Stewart was being downplayed. Supporters of Stewart argued that every championship bid starts with one win, and consistency over time determines a title run, not immediate dominance.
Even fellow riders weighed in, with some expressing that Carmichael’s statement was too dismissive, especially considering Stewart’s progress and his ability to compete with the best.
Is Stewart a Championship Threat?
While Stewart’s victory may not have been a runaway dominant performance, it was still a statement win. His steady improvements, coupled with his ability to match the pace of top contenders, suggest that he could be more of a factor in the championship than Carmichael gives him credit for.
With the season still in its early stages, the real test will be whether Stewart can consistently challenge the likes of Eli Tomac, Chase Sexton, and Cooper Webb. One race doesn’t define a season, but it can certainly be a sign of what’s to come.
Carmichael Stands by His Statement
Despite the backlash, Carmichael has not walked back his comments, maintaining that while Stewart is talented, he has yet to show the week-in, week-out dominance required to be a true championship threat.
Stewart, for his part, has yet to publicly respond, but his best answer may come on the track—with more podiums, wins, and a strong push toward proving his doubters wrong.
As the season progresses, all eyes will be on Malcolm Stewart to see if he can build off this victory and silence the critics—Carmichael included.
