Jeremy McGrath Questions Eli Tomac’s Competitiveness After Injury: ‘Fans Need to Accept Reality’
Eli Tomac has long been one of the most dominant figures in motocross and Supercross, but according to Jeremy McGrath, the seven-time Supercross champion, Tomac’s best days might be behind him—and fans are refusing to see it.
During a recent discussion about Tomac’s anticipated return from injury, McGrath didn’t hold back, stating that while Tomac is still an elite rider, age and injuries don’t forgive.
“Look, Eli’s had an amazing career, but fans have to accept reality,” McGrath said. “He’s in his 30s now, and once you hit that age, everything changes. I know firsthand—it happened to me. When you’re younger, you recover faster, your reaction time is sharper, and your endurance is just different. But once you pass that 30 mark, the younger guys start catching up, and that’s just the way it is.”
Tomac’s Age and Injury: A Career-Changer?
McGrath pointed to past legends like Ricky Carmichael, who dominated the sport in his prime but knew when to walk away as younger riders like Ryan Villopoto and James Stewart started taking over.
“Ricky knew when to step away, but Eli? He’s a warrior, no doubt. But the question is, can he still be the guy he was before this injury?”
Tomac, now 31 years old, suffered a devastating Achilles injury, which kept him out for months. While his return has been highly anticipated, McGrath isn’t convinced he’ll ever be the same rider again.
“It’s not just about healing,” McGrath explained. “It’s about getting that speed back, that aggressiveness. You lose a step after an injury like that—especially at this stage of your career. It’s not about heart or talent, Eli has plenty of that. It’s just what happens when you reach a certain point.”
Tampa Loss: A Sign of Decline?
McGrath also referenced Tomac’s past struggles, particularly his loss at Tampa, as evidence that the sport is shifting.
“Look at what happened in Tampa,” McGrath said. “He wasn’t the same guy. The younger riders have caught up, and after an injury like this, it’ll be even harder for him to get back on top.”
Tomac’s fans have remained fiercely loyal, refusing to believe he’s past his prime, but McGrath thinks that’s just wishful thinking.
“Eli’s fans are passionate, and I get that. But they need to see the reality. This sport is unforgiving, and Father Time is undefeated.”
Can Tomac Prove McGrath Wrong?
Despite McGrath’s doubts, Tomac has always thrived under pressure, and this could be the biggest challenge of his career. While skeptics believe his prime has passed, only time will tell if he can defy the odds and return to championship form.
One thing is for sure—when Eli Tomac lines up at the gate again, all eyes will be watching.
Leave a Reply