REPORT:Looking Back: Is St. Louis Misjudging the Decision to Scratch Xhekaj?…..read more…..
—
Looking Back: Is St. Louis Misjudging the Decision to Scratch Xhekaj?
In the world of hockey, roster decisions are often met with scrutiny, and right now, Martin St. Louis is facing some of that heat. The Montreal Canadiens’ head coach raised eyebrows recently by scratching defenseman Arber Xhekaj from the lineup—a move that has sparked debate among fans and analysts alike. As the Habs navigate the latter part of the season, questions loom: Is benching Xhekaj a tactical decision, or is it a misstep that could impact the team’s future?
The X-Factor on Defense
Arber Xhekaj isn’t your typical defenseman. Known for his physical style of play, fearless attitude, and ability to stand up for teammates, Xhekaj quickly became a fan favorite in Montreal. Undrafted but undeterred, he fought his way into the NHL with a story that resonates—grit, determination, and perseverance.
At just 23 years old, Xhekaj has shown flashes of becoming a solid top-four defenseman. He brings a unique presence on the ice: not only does he throw his weight around and protect the crease, but he also contributes offensively with a heavy shot and improving puck movement. So when his name was left off the lineup card, many were left scratching their heads.
Martin St. Louis’ Vision
Martin St. Louis, a former NHL star himself, has never been shy about doing things his own way. As a coach, he’s emphasized speed, creativity, and smart puck management. His philosophy leans heavily on development, particularly with the Canadiens still very much in a rebuilding phase.
According to St. Louis, scratching Xhekaj wasn’t a punishment but part of a broader developmental plan. In post-game interviews, he suggested the decision was made to give Xhekaj a better perspective on the game and time to reset mentally. While such moves can be beneficial in certain contexts, the timing and frequency of these healthy scratches have sparked concern.
Mixed Results on the Ice
Since Xhekaj’s absence from the lineup, the Canadiens’ defensive unit has looked noticeably thinner. While young blueliners like Kaiden Guhle and Jordan Harris continue to develop, the physical edge that Xhekaj brings has been sorely missed. Opposing teams have exploited Montreal’s lack of pushback, and the defensive zone coverage has looked disorganized at times.
This isn’t to say that Xhekaj is without fault—he’s still learning the nuances of positioning and discipline. But for a team not currently in playoff contention, giving young players consistent ice time to learn from their mistakes seems like a logical path forward. Removing Xhekaj from the lineup could be slowing his growth, not helping it.
Fans and Analysts Weigh In
The Canadiens’ faithful are passionate, and many have taken to social media and talk shows to voice their frustration. Hashtags supporting Xhekaj trended briefly in Montreal, and several pundits questioned whether St. Louis is overthinking a relatively straightforward situation.
Analyst Marc Denis commented during a recent broadcast, “You’ve got a young defenseman who brings something no one else on your roster does. You can’t replicate his toughness or energy. If this is about development, then let him develop—on the ice.”
Even former NHLers have chimed in, suggesting that scratching Xhekaj repeatedly could damage his confidence. Others have defended St. Louis, believing that temporary benchings could be part of a long-term strategy to make Xhekaj a more complete player.
Balancing Development and Identity
The Canadiens are in a tricky spot. They’re rebuilding, yes, but they’re also trying to establish an identity. A team’s identity is often forged in the character of its players, and Arber Xhekaj has the makings of a foundational piece—tough, loyal, and constantly striving to improve.
By sidelining him, the coaching staff risks dulling that edge. While it’s true that players need to earn their ice time and work through adversity, there’s a fine line between motivating and marginalizing.
The Road Ahead
Montreal’s season will likely end without a playoff berth, but the final stretch of games still carries meaning. It’s an opportunity to evaluate talent, build chemistry, and give young players the reps they need to grow. For Xhekaj, that means being on the ice—not in the press box.
Whether Martin St. Louis’ approach pays off remains to be seen. If Xhekaj returns stronger and more well-rounded, St. Louis will be vindicated. But if his confidence wanes or if the Canadiens continue to falter without his physical presence, critics will only grow louder.
In hindsight, this decision could define how St. Louis is viewed as a developmental coach. For now, it remains a calculated gamble with the spotlight squarely on the bench.
